Review: The Curious Savage by City Theatre Company
by David Glen Robinson
John Patrick's 1950 comedy The Curious Savage is a must-see for connoisseurs of farce. Set in a psychiatric asylum, it presents a collection of odd but benign characters who approach major life problems they can’t understand with only the tools they have. The results are hilarious, never condescending, and ultimately wise and life-affirming. Payton Trahan directs.
Patrick has many theatre and film credits. Teahouse of the August Moon is his most recognized work, first as a Broadway play (1953) and then as an MGM movie. That work, set during the U.S. occupation of Japan, is charming but patronizing and unplayable today. The Curious Savage, one of his many comedies, is still produced in community theatres.
The Curious Savage reflects 1950s pro-U.S. values. Patrick was a WWII veteran although with UK forces. Modern audiences will see the asylum characters merely as oddballs, the kind we might see walking the streets talking to the clouds, not in confinement. The play is a comedy, after all.
The stage set is a day room of a somewhat upscale class residential institution where residents spend their days playing Parcheesi or making screeking noises on a violin (that's Hannibal, played by Leland Miles). Into this sunshine world comes Mrs. Savage (Kristin Fern Johnson). Obviously of the American aristocracy, Mrs. Savage comes in speaking non sequiturs that don’t quite wash as crazy talk. She casts suspicious side eyes at all around her. She won’t let anyone touch her one-eyed teddy bear. Our protagonist is no good at playing a nutter. We are instantly cued that it's all about Mrs. Savage and we're right. We know that she carries the secret and key to the play. Within minutes, we hear that Mrs. Savage’s greedy family (wealthy but in process of losing it all) has committed her, in perfect sanity and much too shrewd, to the sanatorium, no doubt to force her to cough up the wealth she has sequestered.
The family of Savages is a separate set of characters significantly contrasting with those living “on the inside.” Titus (Darren Scharf) is a senator and the leader of Mrs. Savage’s three stepchildren. His two siblings, celebrity glamor puss Lily Belle (Shanaya Dixon) and lawyer Samuel (Bright Douglas) rival one another in greed. Their attitudes and actions are comic and more stereotypically insane than those of the inmates. Perhaps that's meant to be the life-lesson of the entire play.

Mrs. Savage sneakily sends the stepchildren separately on fool’s errands to find the money in improbable places (well-guarded or under ten feet of mud, etc.) When they return to the day room in the second act, battered and well-grimed, the inmates defend Mrs. Savage from their verbal assaults, until the well-worn trope appears. Someone turns out the lights and achieves a radical plot twist. The happy ending ensues—though only after considerable overwriting by Patrick. This redoubtable cast follows the text devotedly to arrive at clear explications of the story threads. The action might best be thought of as following the old joke cliché: “We might be crazy but that doesn’t mean we’re stupid!” The play ends with a beautiful stage coda not to be spoiled here.
Kristin Fern Johnson as Mrs. Savage does the heavy lifting in explaining everything. Darren Scharf as her stepson Titus drives the play emotionally, his rages setting all the other characters in their places. Kudos to both for accomplishing a lot of creative work. Marc Carlson plays Dr. Emmett, manager of the asylum. The rest of the characters “on the inside” were played by Emily-Ann Patterson, Leland Miles, Sara Barber, Chris Cook, Savannah Martinez, and Regina Grimes.
The Curious Savage by John Patrick runs until November 22, 2026, at City Theatre’s Genesis Creative Collective in central Austin. The play, with the cleanest material I’ve seen in some while, is recommended to all adults and percipient childrenor for an evening’s entertainment.
The Curious Savage
by John Patrick
City Theatre Company
November 06 - November 22, 2026